Post by Mustex on Mar 20, 2005 8:47:34 GMT -5
O.k., I'm sure you all remember Entertainment Weekly's rude comment about both BSG fandoms. Anyway, I forgot to mention when AOC came out they changed their tone and gave it a B. Here's the final kicker, though. For next week (I have it in front of me, and will copy word-for-word):
It should be noted that higher than B+'s are usually reserved for Emmy/Oscar winners, and with the first comment it was also pointed out that NBC is a rival to the people who own EW, so they don't want TNS to look too good.
Stargate SG-1, Stargate Atlantis, Battlestar Galactica
(Sci Fi) SG-1 kicks off a night of cosmic catharsis with a sci-fi chestnut: the alternative timeline episode, where one screw-up in the past wrecks the present (did no one see Back to the Future?!). Atlantis, meanwhile, enters The Matrix (Revolutions, sadly) but with a less satisfying firefight and none of Keanu's comic genius. And Battlestar (above) gets it right: Mutinous standoffs, surprise assassinations, and hot blondes brawling on a radioactive planet-now that's how you end a season.
SG-1: C Atlantis: C Battlestar: B+ -Neil Drumming
(Sci Fi) SG-1 kicks off a night of cosmic catharsis with a sci-fi chestnut: the alternative timeline episode, where one screw-up in the past wrecks the present (did no one see Back to the Future?!). Atlantis, meanwhile, enters The Matrix (Revolutions, sadly) but with a less satisfying firefight and none of Keanu's comic genius. And Battlestar (above) gets it right: Mutinous standoffs, surprise assassinations, and hot blondes brawling on a radioactive planet-now that's how you end a season.
SG-1: C Atlantis: C Battlestar: B+ -Neil Drumming
It should be noted that higher than B+'s are usually reserved for Emmy/Oscar winners, and with the first comment it was also pointed out that NBC is a rival to the people who own EW, so they don't want TNS to look too good.
